Tips for Success
Like most keto fudge recipes, this does get a bit soft at room temperature, so it’s best stored in the fridge. However, it can sit out on the counter for several hours if you are serving it to guests.
Unsweetened chocolate is temperamental and can seize when subjected to too much heat. Be sure to remove the hot cream mixture from the heat before adding the chopped chocolate. Also make sure not to allow any water into the mix, as that will cause it to seize as well.
It’s best to use a good quality unsweetened chocolate, such as Guittard or Ghirardelli. I find that Baker’s brand tends to seize more easily than higher quality brands.
Troubleshooting: If your mixture does seize or begin to separate during the process, you can often rescue it by beating with a hand mixer on low and slowly increasing the speed as it begins to come together. This can also work in a blender if you have one that has a low setting.
To cut keto fudge into perfect squares, heat up a sharp knife. I like to hold mine over the flame of my gas stove for 5 seconds. You can also run some boiling water from a kettle over the blade.
Collagen substitutions: The collagen in this recipe provides a wonderful chewy quality and also some additional structure. You can use unflavored, chocolate, or vanilla. If you prefer to skip it, then I recommend adding another tablespoon each of cocoa powder and powdered sweetener.
One reader indicated that they swapped the collagen for some chocolate whey protein powder and that worked as well. I have not tried it myself so I can’t really say for certain.
Sweetener Options
I know it would be simpler if there was just one go-to sweetener that worked in every application. But that is often not the case with alternative ingredients. I recommend using a powdered erythritol-based sweetener to help set the keto fudge properly, and a little allulose (or xylitol) to keep it from recrystallizing.
I do not recommend using only allulose or xylitol in this recipe, as it will be far too soft and may not ever set properly. I don’t recommend cutting back more on the erythritol more, as it helps the fudge set. However, if you do try it, you may want to add another tablespoon or two of cocoa powder to give it more structure.